Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Integrity Talk's avatar

As a French person who has studied and worked in France, I have very mixed feelings about this narrative. Explaining social inequalities as a result of genetic differences is a reductionist perspective that completely misses the historical context, and if it were true, it would not explain why Moroccans are outrageously successful in French engineering schools, especially the most elitist ones like Polytechnique and Centrale, which are extremely competitive with admission tests that are more challenging than most Ivy Leagues. I've been in the tech industry for over 10 years now, and in most of the companies I've worked for, about 30% of the engineering workforce was from North Africa, more commonly the equivalent of the Indian H-1B worker in US. Of course, these workers are mostly from wealthy families and have a natural advantage in that they speak French. Nonetheless, there is no chance that they could be so dominant in the tech industry, and the French elitist education system, if their average IQ were around 85.

Expand full comment
David's avatar

"I worked with some smart Algerians in tech, so their average IQs can't be 85" is a really low quality trolling that somehow is generating engagement.

A better question to ask is the following: given the geographic proximity of Algeria (and North Africa in general) to Europe and the high European genetic admixture in Algerians, why hasn't Algerians build a prosperous, peaceful, and modern society? Can we quantify the level of European genetic admixture in Algerians and predict their IQ? If you've seen Algerians in person, you'll notice that a lot of them look just like typical Europeans in the Mediterranean regions. Does this guy look particularly North African to you?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zinedine_Zidane#/media/File:Zinedine_Zidane_by_Tasnim_03.jpg

North Africans and Europeans have very close genetic distance. Certainly closer than European and East Asians for example. And the North Africans haven't achieved much in the past 500 years.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts