13 Comments

I think that elites believe they deserve their status because they’re smart, moral, creative, etc. I think they believe the system is unjust but not that all success is undeserved. A lot of people aren’t self critical though and might not have a totally different worldview. It is kind of like blank statism where people are selectively blank statist and don’t think about it and iron out the inconsistencies in their worldview or even critically look at them.

Expand full comment

I just listened to you YT with Dutton. Very good. I spent most of my life confused and bewildered. This IQ stuff explains a lot.

I am writing here not on topic as your SS doesn't seem to show up in my feed nor can I find you in my subscribed channels. Something is wrong?

Expand full comment
Apr 20, 2023·edited Apr 20, 2023Liked by Aporia

I'm not sure why you invent a torturously logical explanation for this insane situation, when there is a much simpler explanation ready to hand. How did these elites attain their position BEFORE the woke madness took over?

That's right - they fought for it, pulled strings and stabbed backs on the way to the top. These are driven, agressive and focussed people. They know that their colleagues are waiting to upend them, and an accusation of racism/sexism/anyism is enough to collapse their career.

So they signal their agreement with ANY woke concept - no matter how ludicrous. Did you see the Anthropology professor claiming that there was no difference between a man's and a woman's skeletons? That is not claiming victimisation - that's wriggling away from ANY possibility that someone will have him cancelled.

For the elites, this is the Reign of Terror from the 1790s. And no one wants to go to the guillotine...

Expand full comment

This reminds me of the book, "The person and the situation" that describes how the environmental context often explains peoples behavior more than their internal traits. The environment of university professors denying IQ is strange until you realize that they are not defending their success at increasing IQ of their students but they are instead reacting to their failure to do so as evidenced by the persistent racial IQ gaps. To protect their jobs and self-image the problem must not be their failure as teachers but instead some external "systemic racism" that they are leading a valiant fight against.

Expand full comment

Right on.

Expand full comment

Have you read Turchin on elite over-production? Your eventual conclusion is entirely consistent with how he describes one part of the process.

Expand full comment

History repeats (as a farce?): Girolamo Savonarola did not make any gople, he was summoned to Florence by Lorenzo De Medici himself, since Savonarola was indeed seen as a moral authority. In a few years, he tried to destroy all the Renaissance jewels produced by the elite that had called him.

Expand full comment